Guest, Sign inJoin

Post to Shelter Island

We’ll email a one-tap link to publish your post. No password, and nothing is public until you click it.
Already a member? Sign in
Shelter Island WindmillPhoto: Hayden Soloviev · CC BY 4.0
AHistory
History · Shelter Island

Shelter Island’s post office opened in 1846, and 23% of its homes were built before 1940

More historic than 93% of U.S. towns · #194 of 758 in New York. What drives it

10 places in town are on the National Register, among them three historic districts with 161 buildings between them. Below: 17 old photos and papers, maps from 1904 on, and the census since 1790.

1846first post office
10on the National Register
23%homes built before 1940
17old photos & papers
4famous people
From Shelter Island’s archive · credits on each photo
Quick answers

How Shelter Island began

When was Shelter Island founded?

1846

The Shelter Island post office opened in 1846, the earliest record of the town by name.

First census: 201 in 17902020 census: 3,253180 years

How historic is Shelter Island?

A

More historic than 93% of U.S. towns, on its age, its old homes and the National Register.

What drives the grade ↓
Founding year: the first Shelter Island post office (Blevins & Helbock, CC0).The full story ↓
History grade

What drives Shelter Island’s History grade

On its age, its old homes and the National Register, Shelter Island is more historic than 93% of U.S. towns, #194 of 758 in New York. All 3 inputs are above most U.S. towns; its National Register listings ranks highest and its share of homes from before 1940 lowest.

A
HistoryA character grade: shown, never part of Shelter Island’s overall grade.
All U.S. towns we grade (21,289)Ahead of 93%
NewerOlder
New York towns of 2,500+ (758)Ahead of 75%

New York towns list more on the Register than most of the country (a typical New York town has 12.3 per 10,000 residents, the U.S. 2.4), so Shelter Island’s 501 sits above most of its state (92% of New York towns have fewer) while its 168 historic buildings outnumber those of 92% of U.S. towns.

How sure. Graded on any two of the three inputs instead, the letter would range from A− to A. The pre-1940 share is a Census survey estimate (±6.7 points). The founding year is the first post office, not a stated founding date.

Founding year: the first post office (other dates in Quick answers). Homes: Census ACS 2020–24. National Register: National Park Service, May 2026 list; each listing counted once (boundary changes and added documentation belong to their listing), and a historic district counts its contributing buildings. How TownRatings grades history →

What stands out about Shelter Island’s past

Read from the archive, the National Register and the record. The page puts what stands out first.

★ What stands out · On the National Register

10 listings protect 168 historic buildings

The country’s official list of buildings and places worth saving.

places listed
10
National Historic Landmarks
0
none yet
historic buildings protected
168
each building in a district counts
first listed
1978
Shelter Island Windmill
All 10 listings

National Park Service, National Register of Historic Places. Photos from Wikimedia Commons, credited on each place’s page.

By decade

Shelter Island, decade by decade

4 decades in the archive, from the 1830s to the 1900s. Scroll each row; tap a photo for its story.

On the map

Shelter Island on the map, 1904 to 1956

Every edition of the U.S. Geological Survey’s map of Shelter Island. Tap a year, or press play to watch the town change.

Shelter Island on the 1904 USGS mapShelter Island on the 1947 USGS mapShelter Island on the 1956 USGS map1904Shelter Island sheet · 1:62,500

U.S. Geological Survey historical topographic maps (public domain), via Esri’s collection of the scans. The red ring marks the center of Shelter Island.

The story

How Shelter Island came to be

From Wikipedia’s history of Shelter Island.

Read it all →

The island was long inhabited by indigenous peoples, related to those who lived north of Long Island Sound. At the time of European encounter, it was occupied by the Manhanset tribe, an Algonquian-speaking people related to the Pequot and other Algonquians of New England. The original name of the island, used by the Manhanset Indians, is Manhansack-aha-quash-awamock, which literally translates to "Island sheltered by islands."

Text from Wikipedia, licensed CC BY-SA 4.0.

From the old history books

What they wrote about Shelter Island in 1882

Passages that mention Shelter Island, cut from the printed page as they were published.

In the spring of 1866 the doctor was elected supervisor of the town of Shelter Island, and with the exception of one year he held the office for the fourteen succeeding terms. In the board of supervisors he was placed upon important committees and was once elected chairman of the board.
...History of Suffolk county, New York1882Read the page →
Read the text

In the spring of 1866 the doctor was elected supervisor of the town of Shelter Island, and with the exception of one year he held the office for the fourteen succeeding terms. In the board of supervisors he was placed upon important committees and was once elected chairman of the board.

Text read by machine from the scan; it may contain errors.
make improvements upon Gardiner's Island in 1639. During the following year settlements were made at Southampton and Southold. Easthampton was settled in 1648, Shelter Island in 1652, Huntington in 1653, Brookhaven in 1655 and Smithtown about 1663. The latter, however, was not recognized as a disti…
...History of Suffolk county, New York1882 · page 56Read the page →
Read the text

make improvements upon Gardiner's Island in 1639. During the following year settlements were made at Southampton and Southold. Easthampton was settled in 1648, Shelter Island in 1652, Huntington in 1653, Brookhaven in 1655 and Smithtown about 1663. The latter, however, was not recognized as a distinct town until several years latter. Neither did Shelter Island exercise the functions of an independent town for

Text read by machine from the scan; it may contain errors.

Scans and text from the Internet Archive. Books published in 1930 or earlier, which are in the public domain.

Timeline

Shelter Island, 1734 to 1937

Woven from the archive, old maps, post office records, the National Register and the people born here.

  1. 18th century
  2. 1734Born herePeter Silvester is born here
  3. 1757Born hereJonathan Nicoll Havens is born here
  4. 19th century
  5. 1834In the archiveUntitled photo
  6. 1846Post officeThe Shelter Island post office opens
  7. 1854Born hereDe Lancey Nicoll is born here
  8. 1880In the archiveManhanset House, north veranda
  9. 1886Post officeThe Shelter Island Heights post office opens
  10. 1890In the archiveUntitled (Shelter Island)title QS:P1476,en:"Untitled (Shelter Island)"label QS:Len,"Untit…
  11. 20th century
  12. 1900In the archivePresdeleau
  13. 1904On the mapFirst mapped by the U.S. Geological Survey
  14. 1910Born hereElbert N. Carvel is born here
  15. 1937BuiltSmith-Taylor Cabin is built
Every building

Shelter Island, building by building, 1917

Fire insurance maps drew every building, what it was made of and what it was used for, so insurers could price the risk of fire. Pick a sheet.

Shelter Island fire insurance map, 1917, sheet 11917Sheet 1 of 6

Sanborn Map Company, via the Library of Congress. Editions published in 1930 or earlier, which are in the public domain.

Then & now

Stand where they stood

No then-and-now pairs yet. Take a photo from the same spot as an old one and they appear here side by side.

Manhanset House, north veranda
Retake this viewManhanset House, north veranda, 1880

Find the spot, match the angle, and add your photo. It becomes the first then-and-now pair on Shelter Island’s page.

Retake this view · +15
People over time

Shelter Island, census by census

05001,0001,5002,0002,5003,0003,500180018501900195020003,253

Grew from 201 people in 1790 to 3,253 in 2020, more than tenfold.

24 censuses, 1790–2020.

U.S. Census Bureau decennial counts, from the census table on Shelter Island’s Wikipedia page.

Famous people

4 famous people were born in Shelter Island

Writers, athletes, leaders and more, ranked by how widely they’re known.

See all →
Places that used to be

Old corners and burying grounds

Shelter Island’s post office has been open since 1846.

Shelter Island
1846–today
Shelter Island Heights
1886–today
18401930today
Hamlets and corners on the map
Dering HarborMontclair ColonyShelter Island HeightsSilver BeachWestmoreland
6cemeteries and burying grounds inside Shelter Island
NicholsOur Lady of the IsleQuakerSaint Mary's EpiscopalShelter IslandShelter Island Presbyterian

US Post Offices dataset (Blevins & Helbock, CC0). Places and cemeteries from the USGS Geographic Names Information System (2021).

Help out

Finish Shelter Island’s story

Most archives stop around 1920. The photos from after that are in family albums, not libraries.

Decades since 1900 with photos
00s10s20s30s40s50s60s70s80s90s
1 of 10 decades. The empty ones are waiting for someone’s album.
Stories next door

History across the town line

Each neighbor’s History grade, on the same three inputs.

Questions about Shelter Island’s history

What year was Shelter Island founded?

The Shelter Island post office opened in 1846, the earliest record of the town by name (U.S. post office records).

How does Shelter Island rank for history?

Shelter Island is more historic than 93% of U.S. towns, #194 of 758 in New York. The History grade combines the town’s founding era, the share of homes built before 1940 and its National Register listings. It’s a character grade, so it isn’t part of the overall grade. How it works.

What is on the National Register in Shelter Island?

10 listings: 5 buildings, among them the Shelter Island Windmill (listed 1978, the first), 3 historic districts, the Shelter Island Heights Historic District, the Camp Quinipet and the Sylvester Manor, with 161 contributing buildings, 1 site, and 1 structure. 168 historic buildings in all.

How old are the homes in Shelter Island?

23% of Shelter Island’s homes were built before 1940 (Census estimate, ±6.7 points), against a typical 27% for a New York town; the median home was built in 1980.

Memory lane

What the archives can’t tell you, neighbors can.

Town Square →
Start a conversation
Sources

Where this page comes from

Founding dates: Wikidata, Wikipedia, the U.S. post office records of Blevins & Helbock (CC0) and the Census. Homes by year built: Census ACS 2020–24. National Register of Historic Places: National Park Service (list of May 22, 2026). Old photos, postcards and papers: Wikimedia Commons, the Library of Congress and other public archives, credited on each item’s page. Maps: U.S. Geological Survey historical topographic maps (via Esri) and Sanborn fire-insurance maps (Library of Congress). History text and census tables: Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 4.0). Places that used to be: USGS Geographic Names Information System (2021).

From Wikimedia Commons (3), the Library of Congress (14), the National Register of Historic Places (10), Wikipedia, Wikidata and Wikipedia for famous people, U.S. Geological Survey historical maps, U.S. Census counts (via Wikipedia), the US Post Offices dataset (Blevins & Helbock), the USGS Geographic Names Information System, Sanborn fire insurance maps (Library of Congress) and old county and town histories (Internet Archive). Archive images are copied here with their credits and licenses, shown on each photo’s page. Refreshed monthly.