Guest, Sign inJoin

Post to Shelter Island

We’ll email a one-tap link to publish your post. No password, and nothing is public until you click it.
Already a member? Sign in
Shelter Island WindmillPhoto: Hayden Soloviev · CC BY 4.0
A+Outdoors
Outdoors in Shelter Island

Shelter Island has 2,484 acres of parks, 740 for every 1,000 residents

34% of Shelter Island’s land is conserved, about 2,634 acres. 21 miles of mapped trail cross Shelter Island, 1.7 per square mile of land. The biggest trail networks: Mashomack Preserve (15 mi).

Ahead of 98% of U.S. towns · #35 of 758 in New York. What drives it

Conserved land
34%
2,634 acres · of 12.2 sq mi of land
Trails
21 mi
1.7 per sq mi of land
Park land
2,484 ac
740 acres per 1,000 residents
Near a park
81%
of residents within ½ mile
Lakes & rivers
6
12 beaches · 17 boat launches

What kind of outdoors town is Shelter Island?

Read from the map. The page puts what stands out first.

Outdoors grade

How much outdoors does Shelter Island have?

On conserved land, trails, park land and how close residents live to a park, Shelter Island is ahead of 98% of U.S. towns, #35 of 758 in New York. All four inputs are above most U.S. towns; park acres per resident rank highest, the share of residents near a park lowest.

A+
OutdoorsA character grade: shown, never part of Shelter Island’s overall grade.
All U.S. towns we grade (21,298)Ahead of 98%
LessMore
New York towns of 2,500+ (758)Ahead of 96%

Water is more than half of Shelter Island’s area (17 of 29 square miles), so every share here is of land; over land and water together, the conserved share would read 14%.

How sure. Graded on any three of the four inputs instead, the letter would range from A to A+. Trails and many small parks come from OpenStreetMap, mapped by volunteers, so coverage varies from town to town; the half mile is a straight line from each census block, so a river or highway in the way isn’t counted against it.

PAD-US, OpenStreetMap (© OpenStreetMap contributors), Census 2025 Gazetteer and 2020 blocks; details in Sources below. How TownRatings grades the outdoors →

The map

Conserved land, trails & bike routes

Tap a number to zoom to a park. Tap a layer to hide it.

12
Easements protect land from building but are usually private.© OpenStreetMap contributors · USGS PAD-US
Places to walk

Pick a walk

The longest trail network is Mashomack Preserve, with 15 miles. Directions go to the nearest trailhead or public parking.

Mashomack Preserve

Nature preserve
1,654 acres15 mi of trail
Dog rules not recorded
Directionsto the parking lot

Shelter Island State Tidal Wetland

Managed by New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
38 acres
Dog rules not recorded
No trailhead mapped yetWebsite ↗
Who protects it

2,634 conserved acres

34% of Shelter Island’s land. Water is left out: Shelter Island has 12.2 square miles of land and 16.5 of water, so the share counts land only. Who manages Shelter Island’s conserved land, from the USGS Protected Areas Database. Approximate, because parcels can overlap.

Land trusts & nonprofits4,773 ac
Town or city114 ac
State conservation38 ac
Other or Unknown Local Government33 ac
USDA easements (NRCS)26 ac
County23 ac
Regional agency8 ac
Private Conservation · 4,763 acLocal Park · 137 acState Conservation Area · 38 acLocal Conservation Area · 27 acAgricultural Easement · 26 ac
Good to know

Conserved doesn’t always mean open to visitors. 32 acres are conservation easements, usually private land. Public access isn’t recorded for 5 of 25 parcels. The walks above are places people visit.

The biggest protected parcels
Parcel (PAD-US)Managed byAcresPublic access
Mashomack Preserve
Private Conservation
Land trusts & nonprofits4,721Open
Town of Shelter Island Land
Local Park
Town or city111Unknown
Shelter Island State Tidal Wetland
State Conservation Area
State conservation38Open
Mashomack
Private Conservation
Land trusts & nonprofits31Open
Ram Island County Park
Local Park
County16Open
Shelter Island Town Lands
Local Conservation Area
Other or Unknown Local Government14Restricted
Dering Village Lands
Local Conservation Area
Other or Unknown Local Government14Restricted
County of Suffolk Land
Local Park
County8Unknown
Shelter Island School District Land
Local Other or Unknown
Regional agency8Unknown
Dering Harbor Village Lands
Local Other or Unknown
Other or Unknown Local Government5Unknown

5 smaller protected places aren’t shown.

Things to do

31 places to go in Shelter Island

Beaches, playgrounds, peaks, falls and more. Pick a kind.

Beaches in Shelter Island
Crescent Beach
Directions
Gibsons Beach
Directions
Lower Beach
Directions
Menhaden Lane Beach
Directions
Shell Beach
Directions
Upper Beach
Directions
Wade's Beach
Directions

Plus 5 beaches without a name on the map. Tap “Show all on map” to see them.

Trails & water

6 lakes & rivers

Biking & sports

0.0 miles of bike routes

Bike lanes are often missing from the map in smaller towns, so that number is likely low.

Courts & fields
56Tennis
4Basketball
1Skate park

Includes school and college facilities, which aren’t always open to the public.

History along the way

10 places on the National Register

The country’s official list of places worth saving (National Park Service).

History →
Shelter Island WindmillBuilding · listed 1978
About it
Union ChapelBuilding · listed 1984
About it
James Havens HomesteadBuilding · listed 1986
About it
Shelter Island Heights Historic DistrictDistrict · listed 1993
About it
Manhanset ChapelBuilding · listed 1997
About it
Camp QuinipetDistrict · listed 2005
About it
Smith-Taylor CabinBuilding · listed 2007
About it
Shelter Island Country ClubSite · listed 2009
About it
Sylvester ManorDistrict · listed 2015
About it
Smith-Ransome Japanese BridgeStructure · listed 2018
About it
When to get out

The best walking months in Shelter Island: May to September

NOAA’s 1991–2020 normals for the town and the daylight at its latitude. Outlined months have long days, highs of 59 to 86 °F and little rain for the place.

JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
Daylight (h)9.510.611.813.314.515.114.813.812.411.09.89.2
High (°F)394147576675818074645445
Rain (in)3.53.14.43.93.43.73.03.73.94.53.74.5

July is the driest month (3.0 in) and the warmest (highs of 81 °F). 4.5 inches fall in October, the wettest month. The climate in Shelter Island →

Next door

Shelter Island and its neighbors

Tap a town to see its outdoors.

TownConserved
of land
Trail mi
per sq mi
Park acres
per 1,000
Near a park
½ mile
Outdoors
Shelter Island34%1.774081%A+
Southold11%0.88092%A
East Hampton34%2.633476%A+
Shelter Island Heights— not graded: under 1,000 residents or part of its town
Northwest Harbor— not graded: under 1,000 residents or part of its town
Greenport West— not graded: under 1,000 residents or part of its town
East Marion— not graded: under 1,000 residents or part of its town
Southampton22%1.923779%A+

The four inputs of the Outdoors grade, from the engine; shares are of land, not water.

Questions about parks and trails in Shelter Island

Where can I hike in Shelter Island?

The longest trail networks: Mashomack Preserve, 15 miles. Each one is on the map above, with directions to the nearest trailhead or parking.

How much of Shelter Island is conserved land?

34% of its land, against a typical 5% for a New York town and 4% nationally (PAD-US). Conserved doesn’t always mean open to visitors: easements are usually private land.

Are dogs allowed on Shelter Island’s trails?

Mashomack Preserve and Shelter Island State Tidal Wetland don’t have dog rules recorded on the map; check the signs at the trailhead.

Is there public land near Shelter Island?

9,731 acres of parks and open public land lie inside Shelter Island or within 10 miles of it (PAD-US), 2,484 of them inside the town line.

How much outdoors does Shelter Island have?

Ahead of 98% of U.S. towns on the Outdoors grade, #35 of 758 in New York. The grade combines the share of land that is conserved, miles of mapped trail per square mile of land, park acres per 1,000 residents and the share of residents within a half mile of a park. It’s a character grade, so it isn’t part of the overall grade. How it works.

Trail talk

Conditions, parking and favorite walks from Shelter Island neighbors.

Town Square →
Share a tip
Sources

Where this page comes from

Conserved and public land: USGS Protected Areas Database of the United States (PAD-US), service updated July 2026. Parks, trails, playgrounds, beaches and other places: OpenStreetMap (© OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL), map data as of 2026-10-28. Land and water area: Census 2025 Gazetteer. Residents near a park: 2020 Census blocks. National Register: National Park Service. How TownRatings grades the outdoors →