Places in Shelter Island
Beaches, eats & places to stay in Shelter Island
154 places in Shelter Island: 17 places to eat and drink, 15 shops, 36 things to do and 7 places to stay. Local spots first, with directions to every one.
All places
154
46 per 1,000 residents
Eat & drink
17
5.1 per 1,000 residents
Shops
15
5 gifts · 2 books
Things to do
36
23 outdoors · 5 arts · 4 landmarks
Places to stay
7
2.1 per 1,000 residents
What kind of places does Shelter Island have?
Read from every listing. The page puts what stands out first.
The map
Where Shelter Island gathers
37 of Shelter Island’s 154 places sit within a five-minute walk of N Ferry Rd.
37places in a five-minute walk of N Ferry Rd24% of Shelter Island’s places
★ What stands out · Things to do
See all →36 things to do
23 parks & outdoors, 5 arts & culture, 4 history & landmarks. Local spots first.
Eat & drink
See all →17 places to eat & drink
5 restaurants, 5 farms & markets, 4 cafés & treats. Local spots first.
Shops
See all →15 shops
5 gifts & boutiques, 2 books & music, 2 home & hardware. Local spots first.
Places to stay
See all →7 places to stay
6 hotels & inns, 1 camping & rentals. Local spots first.
Everyday
See all →61 errands & services
Groceries, gas, the barber, the vet, the bank.
Offices & pros 13The Boathouse Shelter Island · Aerial Hamptons · Debra Von Brook-BinderAuto & gas 7Mobil · Island Shine Auto Detail · Liberty Automotive Repair & TowingHome services 7Reich Eklund Construction · Shelter Island Boats · Shelter Island Funeral HomeGroceries & convenience 5Elli's Country Store · Bottlehouse · Dandy LiquorsHealth care 5Joshua Potter · Optum Internal Medicine - Shelter Island · The Smilist DentalBanks & insurance 4Chase ATM · A and A Williams · Dime Community BankPets 1All Dogged UpOther services 19Shelter Island Whale's Tale · South Ferry Inc. · Piccozzi's Bicycle Rental and Repair
Community
See all →18 schools, churches & public places
Where Shelter Island learns, worships and gets things done.
Town & public services 9Shelter Island Public Library · Shelter Island Fire Department · Town of Shelter Island, NYPlaces of worship 4Shelter Island Presbyterian · Our Lady of the Isle Church · Union Chapel in the GroveCommunity groups 3St. Mary's, Shelter Island · Gardiner's Bay Country Club · Shelter Island Food PantrySchools & childcare 2Shelter Island School · Imagination Island
Next door
Shelter Island and its neighbors
Tap a town to see its places.
Places per 1,000 residents · all places listed
East Hampton52Shelter Island Heights51Shelter Island46Southampton31Southold27East Marion21Talk & tips
Favorites, openings and closings from Shelter Island neighbors.
Weigh in
Is Shelter Island Slice the best place to eat in Shelter Island?
Your answer becomes a post in Town Square.
Share a tip
Some place details from Overture Maps (CDLA-Permissive-2.0), checked against the Census town line. Places added by neighbors go live once a second neighbor confirms them. Spot a mistake? Open the place and tap Edit mode.
How we sort and count
Each list puts neighbor favorites first (ratings and photos), then the most complete listings (a website, a phone number, a note), with local, independent spots ahead of national chains. Categories come from each place’s map category, so a café filed under “Shops” still shows up with the cafés. “A five-minute walk” is a quarter mile from the busiest spot on the map. Per-1,000 figures use the Census population.