Guest, Sign inJoin

Post to Shelter Island

We’ll email a one-tap link to publish your post. No password, and nothing is public until you click it.
Already a member? Sign in
Shelter Island WindmillPhoto: Hayden Soloviev · CC BY 4.0
Town Hall · Shelter Island

Shelter Island spent more per resident in 2022 than 99% of similar towns

Shelter Island’s town government spent $12.5 million on day-to-day services in the year to December 31, 2022, about $5,161 per resident. It also runs a hospital ($11,000), counted separately. Census Bureau figures.

Town website
Day-to-day spending, 2022
$12.5M
year to December 31, 2022
Per resident, 2022
$5,161
In 2022: $5,161, more than 99% of 368 similar towns
Long-term debt
$440,000
end of 2022, reported
Town staff, 2022
62
full-time, hospital & welfare staff apart (62 in all) · March payroll $469,564
Typical tax bill
$5,949
0.54% of home value · NY 1.55%

What stands out about how Shelter Island is run

Read from the town’s budget and official records.

★ What stands out · Your share of the 2022 budget

About $5,161 per resident a year, or $14.14 a day

Day-to-day services only. The biggest line: police, at 17%.

Where the money comes from
Property taxes 53%Other taxes & licenses 33%Fees & charges 6%From the state 4%Interest, fines & other 1%From other local governments 1%From the federal government 1%Sales taxes <1%Utility sales <1%

Revenue is well above spending. That usually means Shelter Island collects property taxes for the school district and county and passes them on, so only its own spending is counted.

Not in the receipt.Building projects $860,000; interest on debt $66,000. With these and the enterprises, the whole budget was $13.5 million.
Why the hospital is apart.The Census Bureau counts the hospital it runs in the town’s books ($11,000, 0% of all operations). Only 135 of the 11,301 towns and cities of 2,500+ run one (Census finance files), so it is shown here and left out of every per-resident comparison.
About “Other”.45% of Shelter Island’s day-to-day spending ($5.7 million) is filed by the Census Bureau outside the named functions above, so the receipt can’t say what it buys.
Compared with similar places

$5,161 per resident in 2022: more than 99% of them

Shelter Island’s day-to-day spending in 2022 ($5,161 per resident, hospital and utilities left out) against 368 New York towns and townships of under 2,500 that don’t run their own schools: the median was $662, and the middle half spent $490–$958. Shelter Island spent more than 99% of them.

Middle half of the group, $490–$958Median $662Shelter Island

Includes sewer and trash ($978,000), as the Census Bureau counts them. Later years come from a Census sample, so the comparison stays on 2022. How Town Hall compares budgets →

The group
368

New York towns and townships of under 2,500 that don’t run their own schools, 2022 Census of Governments (every government counted that year; Shelter Island itself left out).

Over the years

No trend yet

Shelter Island reported only 2022 to the Census Bureau, so there is no trend yet.

Property tax

The typical homeowner pays $5,949 a year

Every local property tax on the home: town, schools and county. About 0.54% of the home’s value, vs 1.55% across New York.

What homes cost →

Typical yearly bill next door and statewide

Northwest Harbor$9,053
Greenport West$8,688
Southold$7,797
East Hampton$7,564
Southampton$7,476
Shelter Island Heights$7,133
New York$6,582
Shelter Island$5,949
East Marion$4,571
$5,949
typical bill a year
0.54%
effective rate
$1,104,300
typical home value (Census)
Your own bill

The Housing page’s calculator splits a monthly payment into loan, tax and insurance at Shelter Island’s rate.

Can I afford it? →

The median bill homeowners report to the Census survey (bills of $10,000+ are reported as “$10,000+”). The effective rate is that bill ÷ the median home value: a rough guide, not the official tax rate.

Tax bills are one input to Shelter Island’s Cost of living grade. Cost of living in Shelter Island →

Who runs it

Who’s in charge in Shelter Island

Names change after every election, so we link to the source that keeps them current.

See shelterislandtown.us for Shelter Island’s current officialsWe name an official only when a public source lists a current term. None does for Shelter Island yet.shelterislandtown.us ↗
Agendas

Shelter Island’s meeting calendar isn’t in our feed yet. The town posts agendas and minutes on shelterislandtown.us ↗.

Who works for Shelter Island

One full-time town employee for every 39 residents, not counting hospital, health & welfare staff

On the payroll in March 2022, from the Census Bureau’s Annual Survey of Public Employment & Payroll. Residents: the Census population in the 2022 finance file (2,419).

By department full-time, plus part-time, March 2022

Administration & buildings18 + 3 pt
Police14 + 4 pt
Sewer & trash11 + 2 pt
Parks & libraries2 + 10 pt
Courts, inspections & corrections2 + 4 pt
Roads & transportation4
Other11 + 8 pt
Run separately
Hospital, health & welfare0 + 2 pt
62
full-time, hospital, health & welfare apart
33
part-time
$469,564
payroll for March 2022
$5.6M
a year, estimated (March × 12)
$81,300
average full-time pay, before benefits (March × 12)
10
sworn police officers
The hospital.The 0 full-time hospital, health & welfare staff include the hospital the town runs, so they are counted apart, as the hospitals are in the budget. The payroll figures cover every employee, the hospital’s included: the Census file doesn’t split pay by function.
Compared, 2022.Shelter Island had 25.6 full-time staff per 1,000 residents in March 2022 (hospital, health & welfare left out, and the same for any peer that runs a hospital). The median for the 295 of the 368 New York towns and townships of under 2,500 that don’t run their own schools that reported 2022 staff was 3.4: Shelter Island had more than 98% of them. Same group and year as the budget comparison.

The Census reports one month’s payroll (March); yearly figures are that month × 12, an estimate. Part-timers count half in the bar lengths.

The school district

Shelter Island Union Free School District

Shelter Island’s K–12 school district, shared with Dering Harbor. It’s its own government, with a budget separate from the town’s.

Schools in Shelter Island →
$59,716
per pupil · NY $34,607
194
students
$1.5 million
long-term debt

Of the $59,716 per pupil, $34,191 goes to the classroom (teachers, aides, supplies); the rest to buses, buildings, counselors and administration. Building projects and debt payments aren’t in the per-pupil figure.

The district: schools, scores and graduation →

Where the district’s money comes from
Local 91%State 8%Federal 2%

New York districts overall: 51% local, 41% state, 8% federal.

School year 2023–24. Census Bureau school finance survey.

Elections · 2024 general election

How Shelter Island voted in 2024

Official results for Shelter Island’s own voters, as certified after the November 5, 2024 general election, with the county and the state beside them.

President2,193 votes · results as certified
Kamala D HarrisKamala D HarrisDemocrat67.6%1,482 votes
Donald J TrumpDonald J TrumpRepublican30.8%676 votes

Others: 1.6% (35 votes).

Most votes in Shelter Island: Kamala D Harris

Suffolk County: Trump 54.3%, Harris 44.4% · New York: Harris 55.9%, Trump 43.3%

Turnout
87%

of Shelter Island’s 2,532 adult citizens voted for president in 2024. Across New York: 59%.

Votes ÷ citizens of voting age (Census CVAP, 2020–24 ACS).

U.S. Senate2,121 votes
Kirsten E GillibrandDemocrat70.1%
Michael D SapraiconeRepublican29.6%
Others0.3%

Most votes in Shelter Island: Kirsten E Gillibrand

Suffolk County: Sapraicone 52.5%, Gillibrand 47.1% · New York: Gillibrand 58.8%, Sapraicone 40.5%

U.S. House · New York’s 1st District409,825 votes
Nicholas J LalotaRepublican55.2%
John P AvlonDemocrat44.8%

Most votes in the district: Nicholas J Lalota

Whole-district result

President, 2024: Shelter Island, its county and the state

HarrisTrumpOthersVotes
Shelter Island67.6%30.8%1.6%2,193
Suffolk County44.4%54.3%1.3%769,435
New York55.9%43.3%0.8%8,262,600
DemocratRepublicanLibertarianIndependent / other

Official 2024 general election returns, as certified (MIT Election Data + Science Lab). Percentages are of votes for candidates; blank and spoiled ballots aren’t counted. Candidates are listed by votes, and party colors are neutral on purpose.

Portraits: Kamala D Harris: official vice-presidential portrait, Lawrence Jackson, The White House, 2021; Donald J Trump: official portrait, Shealah Craighead, The White House, 2017. All are U.S. government works in the public domain. A race shows photos only when every candidate has an official portrait; otherwise every candidate in it gets initials.

Who represents Shelter Island

From town hall to Washington

Every level of government that speaks for Shelter Island.

2024 results ↑
  1. 1
    Your townTown government
  2. 2
    New York AssemblyState representatives
  3. 3
    New York SenateState senator
  4. 4
    GovernorStatewide
  5. 5
    U.S. HouseYour representative in Congress
  6. 6
    U.S. SenateBoth represent all of New York

Democrat · Republican · other or independent. Tap a name for their official page.

Next door

How Shelter Island compares with the towns next door

Shelter Island spent $5,161 per resident in 2022; the 3 neighbors that reported 2022 spent $1,778 to $3,356. Towns that run more services spend more. Tap a town to see its page.

Spends the leastSpends the mostEstimate or no figures
TownDay-to-day, per resident (2022)Tax bill
Southampton$1,778$7,476
Southold$2,016$7,797
East Hampton$3,356$7,564
Shelter Island$5,161$5,949

Day-to-day spending in 2022, the last year every government was counted, for governments that reported it; hospital and utilities left out. Tax bill: the typical homeowner’s bill (Census ACS, 2020–24).

Reach Shelter Island’s government

The official site has phone numbers, hours and forms. Neighbors add the rest to the Handbook.

The Handbook →

Questions about Shelter Island’s government

How much does Shelter Island spend per resident?

About $5,161 per resident on day-to-day services in the year to December 31, 2022, as reported to the Census Bureau. Shelter Island also runs a hospital ($11,000), counted separately. In 2022, the last full count, its $5,161 was more than 99% of 368 New York towns and townships of under 2,500 that don’t run their own schools.

What is the property tax rate in Shelter Island?

Homeowners report a typical bill of $5,949 a year (Census ACS, 2020–24), about 0.54% of the typical home’s value, vs 1.55% across New York. For the official rate per $1,000 of assessed value, see shelterislandtown.us.

Who runs Shelter Island’s government?

See shelterislandtown.us for current officials. We name an official only when a public source lists a current term, and none does for Shelter Island yet.

How did Shelter Island vote in 2024?

For president, Kamala D Harris 67.6%, Donald J Trump 30.8% (2,193 votes, official results). Suffolk County: Trump 54.3%, Harris 44.4%. New York: Harris 55.9%, Trump 43.3%.

How many people work for Shelter Island?

62 full-time and 33 part-time employees in March 2022 (plus 0 full-time hospital, health & welfare staff), with a March payroll of $469,564 (about $5.6M a year if every month were the same), as reported to the Census Bureau.

Who represents Shelter Island in the state legislature?

State Senate District 1 (Tony Palumbo) and Assembly District 1 (Tommy John Schiavoni). The Assembly district also covers 14 other towns. Listed by Open States; districts from the Census Bureau.

Ask neighbors about Shelter Island’s government

Neighbors who’ve been to the meetings can help.

Town Square →
Ask neighbors

Budget and staff: U.S. Census Bureau, Census of Governments (2022, every government) and Annual Survey of State and Local Government Finances (2023–24, a sample) and the Annual Survey of Public Employment & Payroll; day-to-day spending is current operations, with hospitals, utilities and airports apart. School district: Census school finance survey, 2023–24. Property tax: Census American Community Survey, 2020–24. Elections: official 2024 returns via the MIT Election Data + Science Lab; turnout uses Census citizen voting-age population (CVAP, 2020–24). Officials: Open States, names shown only with a current term (checked October 9, 2026). Districts: Census Bureau (119th Congress, 2024 state districts); legislators: Open States and congress-legislators. How Town Hall works →