Where to stay, eat & explore in Shelter Island Heights
63 places in Shelter Island Heights: 14 places to eat and drink, 5 shops, 17 things to do and 8 places to stay. Local spots first, with directions to every one.
All places
63
51 per 1,000 residents
Eat & drink
14
11 per 1,000 residents
Shops
5
Things to do
17
11 outdoors · 1 arts · 3 landmarks
Places to stay
8
6.5 per 1,000 residents
What kind of places does Shelter Island Heights have?
Read from every listing. The page puts what stands out first.
Is Sunset Beach Hotel the best place to eat in Shelter Island Heights?
Your answer becomes a post in Town Square.
What’s missing?
Not on the map yet. It may just be missing.
No bakery listed ·
No pizza place listed ·
No grocery store listed ·
Share a tip
Some place details from Overture Maps (CDLA-Permissive-2.0), checked against the Census town line. Places added by neighbors go live once a second neighbor confirms them. Spot a mistake? Open the place and tap Edit mode.
How we sort and count
Each list puts neighbor favorites first (ratings and photos), then the most complete listings (a website, a phone number, a note), with local, independent spots ahead of national chains. Categories come from each place’s map category, so a café filed under “Shops” still shows up with the cafés. “A five-minute walk” is a quarter mile from the busiest spot on the map. Per-1,000 figures use the Census population.