#1Ralph Wilson Hoyt
1849–1920United States military major general
Each edition grades its towns against each other only.
The united States military major general Ralph Wilson Hoyt was born in 1849. That places their birth in the early republic. Articles about them exist in 2 languages. Of the towns next door, Penn Yan lists the most: 14, with David Bordwell first.

#1United States military major general
Pick one and say why. Your answer becomes a post in Town Square.
Be the first to say who Milo’s most famous person is.
Around it, Penn Yan has the most people on record, 14 of them.
From Wikidata and Wikipedia: people whose birthplace is Milo and whose English Wikipedia article agrees, ranked by how many Wikipedia languages cover each person. People known mainly for crimes, and adult performers, aren’t listed. “The usual town” = everyone born in the towns gathered so far.